‘Saying the quiet part out loud,’ Florida says libraries have first amendment right to take books off shelves

Florida Attorney General Ashley Moody argued for removing certain books from schools, writing that public school libraries are “a forum for government speech,” not a “forum for free expression.”

“They’re finally saying the quiet part out loud,” Florida State House Rep. Anna Eskamani said. “Anytime Republicans scream indoctrination is happening in our schools, it’s actually a projection of what they want to see happen. In Ashley Moody’s submission to the court, she admitted she does not see public education, public institutions or schools as places for free thought but as a place to push the state’s agenda.” Eskamani is a vocal critic of book bans throughout the state.

In the filing, Moody argues for the dismissal of a lawsuit brought by the nonprofit PEN America and authors and publishers of And Tango Makes Three — a children’s book about the true tale of two male penguins adopting a chick and starting a family at the Central Park Zoo — against Escambia County Schools.

The book has been a chief target for conservatives and parental rights groups aiming to remove certain books from school libraries since its release in 2005.

The lawsuit alleges Escambia County School Board violated students’ First Amendment rights based on its disagreement with ideas expressed in certain books and unconstitutionally removed books because of their LGBTQ+ themes and mention of race.

Efforts to restrict access to reading materials in schools nationwide have ramped up in recent years, with Florida leading the charge. The push is backed by a coalition of far-right political activists, Republican lawmakers and parental rights groups like Moms for Liberty who object to the alleged “woke indoctrination” of students. Books regarding gender and sexuality have been targeted more than any other material, according to PEN America.

Escambia County teacher Vicki Baggett is pushing to have more than 100 books, including And Tango Makes Three, removed from public…

Read the full article here


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *