Northern Oklahoma’s first female Cherokee judge has her work cut out for her

Federal courts in Northern Oklahoma have gotten busy since 2020 when the Supreme court ruled half the state is Tribal land. Now, a Cherokee woman is joining the federal court there.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Judge Sara Hill serves on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma. She became the first Native American woman to join its bench when she was confirmed in December, and she begins at a busy time. Cases in the northern district have increased since the 2020 Supreme Court decision. That said, much of the eastern part of Oklahoma is within a Native American reservation. That means certain major criminal cases have to be tried in the federal courts, not state. As Elizabeth Caldwell of member station KWGS reports, Judge Hill has her work cut out for her.

ELIZABETH CALDWELL, BYLINE: In a lounge at the University of Tulsa, a group of judges, professors and tribal officials are gathered to celebrate something that has never happened in Oklahoma before. A Cherokee woman is now a judge in the northern district. Sara Hill joins just a handful of other federal native judges to ever be appointed.

SARA HILL: I’m really excited about it. There’s a lot of work to be done in the northern district, but, you know, that’s what I came to do. I came to work, so I’m excited to get into it.

CALDWELL: Hill was the Cherokee Nation’s attorney general in 2020 when the Supreme Court issued the McGirt decision. It made half of the state tribal lands and upended Oklahoma’s legal landscape. Hill says she’s ready.

HILL: Indian country is always changing. The definitions, the law is always changing. So to some extent, you’re always on a frontier.

CALDWELL: Since the McGirt decision, cases in the northern district have increased 400%, and they include more violent crimes involving tribal members. Before the McGirt ruling, those went to state courts. Hill’s new colleague, Federal Judge Gregory Frizzell, says he welcomes her…